Does IR35 apply to consultants?

The short answer is yes, IR35 can apply to consultants. But whether it actually affects you depends on how you work, who you work for, and how your contracts are structured. Getting this wrong is one of the most expensive tax mistakes a consultant can make.

At APH, we have been advising consultants across the UK on IR35 since 2010. Here are the seven things worth understanding clearly.

1. What IR35 Actually Is

IR35 is HMRC’s off-payroll working legislation. It was introduced to tackle what HMRC calls disguised employment, where someone works essentially as an employee but operates through a limited company to pay less tax.

The legislation applies when a worker provides services through an intermediary, usually their own limited company, and HMRC determines that the working relationship resembles employment rather than genuine self employment.

If IR35 applies to your engagement, the tax efficiency of operating through a limited company disappears entirely.

You pay tax and National Insurance as if you were an employee, but without the employment rights that come with being one.

2. Yes, IR35 Can Apply to Consultants: Here Is When

IR35 applies to consultants who:

  • Operate through their own limited company or personal service company
  • Provide services to a client under arrangements that resemble employment
  • Would be classed as an employee if they were engaged directly by that client

If you are a sole trader, IR35 does not apply to you. The legislation only applies when there is an intermediary, typically a limited company, between you and your client.

If you operate through a limited company and work closely with one client on an ongoing basis, your IR35 position is worth reviewing carefully.

The closer your working arrangements resemble those of a permanent employee, the greater your IR35 exposure.

3. The Three Key Tests HMRC Uses

HMRC assesses IR35 status based on three primary factors. These are the tests that matter most:

  • Control – Does your client control what you do, when you do it, and how you do it? The more control a client has over your day to day work, the more your engagement resembles employment. A genuine consultant should have significant autonomy over how they deliver their work.
  • Substitution – Can you send a suitably qualified substitute to do the work in your place without your client’s approval? If you have a genuine right of substitution and have exercised it, this is a strong indicator of self employment. If your client expects you personally to show up every day, this weighs toward employment.
  • Mutuality of obligation – Is your client obliged to offer you work, and are you obliged to accept it? A genuine business to business relationship has no such mutual obligation. If your client expects ongoing work and you feel obliged to accept it, HMRC may view this as employment.

No single test is conclusive on its own. HMRC looks at the overall picture of the working relationship.

aph acccountants chartered accounting services wirral accountant

4. Who Is Responsible for Determining Your IR35 Status

This depends on the size of the client you are working with.

  • Medium and large clients – If your end client is a medium or large business, they are responsible for assessing your IR35 status and issuing a Status Determination Statement. You cannot override their determination, though you can challenge it through their formal disagreement process.
  • Small clients – If your end client qualifies as a small company, the responsibility for determining IR35 status falls back to you and your limited company. A small company meets at least two of the following: turnover under £10.2 million, balance sheet under £5.1 million, or 50 or fewer employees.
  • Working through a consultancy – If you deliver services through a genuine third party consultancy rather than directly to an end client, the IR35 responsibility shifts to that consultancy rather than the end client.

5. What Happens If You Are Caught Inside IR35

If your engagement is determined to be inside IR35, the tax consequences are significant.

The fee payer, usually your client or their agency, must deduct income tax and National Insurance from your fees before paying you, as if you were an employee. Your limited company receives the net amount after these deductions.

The tax saving from operating through a limited company, the salary and dividend combination, is lost entirely on that engagement.

You effectively pay employment taxes without receiving employment rights such as sick pay, holiday pay, or pension contributions from the client.

If HMRC investigates and finds underpaid tax from historic engagements, you may also face backdated liabilities, interest, and penalties. This is why getting your IR35 position right matters.

Find out more about how we support IT consultants and contractors here.

6. How to Protect Yourself and Work Outside IR35

Working outside IR35 is entirely legitimate. Most genuine consultants, those who operate as independent businesses rather than disguised employees, should be able to demonstrate this clearly.

Practical steps to protect your outside IR35 position:

  • Ensure your contracts accurately reflect the reality of your working arrangements, particularly around control, substitution, and mutuality of obligation
  • Exercise your right of substitution where possible, even once, as evidence of genuine self employment
  • Avoid working exclusively for one client over a long period on arrangements that resemble employment
  • Maintain genuine business infrastructure, your own equipment, insurance, website, and multiple clients where possible
  • Keep records of how your working arrangements demonstrate self employment in practice

The contract alone is not enough. HMRC looks at the actual day to day reality of how you work, not just what the contract says.

Getting a contract review from a specialist before starting a new engagement is good practice, particularly for higher value or longer term contracts.

5 ways to access the right funding for your business aph accountants

7. Why Getting Specialist Advice Matters

IR35 is an area where the cost of getting it wrong significantly outweighs the cost of getting proper advice.

A specialist accountant who understands consultancy can help you assess your IR35 position accurately, review your contracts for risk, advise on how to structure your working arrangements to support an outside IR35 position, and keep you informed as the legislation evolves.

Most consultants who face IR35 problems do so not because they were deliberately avoiding tax, but because they did not fully understand how the rules applied to their specific situation.

At APH, we work with consultants across the UK to make sure their IR35 position is clear, their contracts are sound, and their tax affairs are structured correctly from the start.

What Our Clients Say

Paul Foster
“We are scaling our business and needed to find a company who understood the challenges we were faced with. After speaking to five other companies, APH stood out as the business that had the most knowledge and experience.”

Mike Waywell
“I can’t recommend APH highly enough. They’ve been brilliant supporting me across two different businesses, handling everything from regular tax submissions and bookkeeping right through to restructuring shares and selling one of the companies.”

Frequently Asked Questions

No. IR35 only applies to consultants who operate through an intermediary such as their own limited company. Sole traders are not affected by IR35, though HMRC may still scrutinise their employment status through other means.

Yes. IR35 is assessed on a contract by contract basis, not across your entire consultancy. You may be outside IR35 for most of your work but inside for a specific engagement where the working arrangements more closely resemble employment.

A Status Determination Statement is a written assessment from your medium or large client setting out whether your engagement falls inside or outside IR35. Clients are legally required to issue one and must take reasonable care in making their determination.

Yes. If your medium or large client determines you are inside IR35 and you disagree, you can challenge their determination through their formal disagreement process. They must respond within 45 days.

Yes, the same IR35 rules apply to management consultants as to any other type of consultant operating through a limited company. The key question is always whether the working arrangements resemble employment rather than genuine business to business consulting.

Speak to an advisor

Please contact us if you need further advice, have any questions about our services, or would like a free consultation or a fixed quote.

copilot